Criticism, the Importance of Balance, and Your Happiness

Written by

in

A man in a button-up shirt, red circular glasses, wild hair, and a dead pan facial expression holds a thumbs-down gesture
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

I don’t know about you, but when I was in high school and college, I was a hypercritical little shit. I think that gives me valuable perspective today when I encounter hypercritical little shits on the Internet.

It seems to me some readers are intent on drawing displeasure from whatever they read and then regurgitating it into the Internet where kindred readers come slurp it up like a hatred smoothie to fuel their self righteousness and douse their inferiority complexes.

I can write that because I was that kind of person.

I’m happy to debate the utility of criticism in the general health of any art form. It’s good. It’s necessary. However, criticism is a skill, and like any skill, it takes time to learn and develop. It is so significant that a large portion of any arts education curriculum focuses on it.

Here’s an idea that might strike you as wild: criticism is not inherently negative. Good criticism is balanced. Whereas analysis seeks to understand a piece of art, criticism seeks to understand one’s relationship with that art. What works for you and why are just as important pieces of criticism as what doesn’t work for you and why, and too often, the former is disregarded or neglected in favor of the latter.

Creative writing pedagogy has evolved dramatically since I was in an undergrad program. Generally, it’s far more constructive than destructive, though there are still holdout authors teaching thick-skin fallacies and forcing scar tissue onto young writers who are learning maybe they can’t be writers or just aren’t good at writing or questioning why they ever wanted to be a writer in the first place.

A pedagogy of destruction isn’t healthy, but my point is, when I had the opportunity to teach creative writing to undergraduates, I set a few fundamental rules to pervade every class session. Number one? Our collective goal as a cohort was to ensure every writer leaves class each day energized and motivated to keep working because we’ve helped them chart a path forward, even if that path involves some corrections. I wish I knew where my students were today and if they found that approach helpful, but I take it on faith they did because that was what I needed when I was their age: fuel for my internal fire; nourishment and guidance.

Back to me as a hypercritical little shit. I spent years (maybe a full decade, if I were to honestly look at a calendar) consuming every story, book, movie, TV show, video game, etc. from a perspective of criticism, but I was never taught what criticism really was. I did this because I was seeking to understand all of these pieces of art that I was passionate about and what my relationship with them was. I did it because I was trying to grow as an artist. I was greedily gobbling up anything I could and analyzing and scrutinizing it for its imperfections, rough edges, marred surfaces, and missing pieces, and I was teaching myself lessons about what not to do because, and this is important, that was how I was taught to grow as an artist.

Trouble is I’ve learned that’s an awful way to grow as an artist, and I’ve developed far more as a writer by seeking lessons about what to do, because that’s the stuff that inspires me. That’s the stuff that energizes and motivates me and makes me want to push myself to be better and make better art.

When I was reading other writers’ work from a perspective of narcissism and self righteousness, it felt good to convince myself I was a better writer than other writers, but it didn’t motivate me to write. Why would it? I was already better, and no, the fact that these other writers’ had achieved and succeeded in publishing their writing didn’t faze this delusion of mine, because I didn’t need to publish to know I was a better writer. It was self-evident in the failures that I recognized in the work.

I would like to say I had a revelation or epiphany that changed my perspective, but the truth is I got tired and bored. Every story looked the same, and everything I picked up was a disappointment, except for the truly great works (that I alone seemed to recognize as great).

The change, for me, happened in my late ’20s, or thereabouts, when I made a conscious decision to focus on success versus failure. That was like adrenaline for my creative artistry, and wouldn’t you know it? That’s when I started writing and publishing consistently.

When I see the self-righteous, inferiority-complex-suffering, hypercritical little shits on the Internet who espouse their critiques rife with insufferable negativity, my reflex is to wonder what would motivate someone to put such toxicity into an already-toxic world, but then I remember the era in my creative development that I’m embarrassed by. I understand the compulsion of such readers to deconstruct and dismantle a story, and I understand the purpose such readers think it serves.

But the truth is the only people those readers are serving are themselves and other readers who feel fortified by consuming others’ self-righteousness.

Actually, that’s more of a disservice, isn’t it?

To those readers, try this challenge: for a full year, seek only to understand where stories you consume succeed for you. Let the failures pass through a strainer and flow down a drain so you keep only the good stuff. Commit to this. Help yourself by consuming stories that you are confident you’ll enjoy, not stories others dictate you should enjoy. What can you learn from every piece’s successes? What can you take from it that energizes, motivates, and inspires you? How can you use each story you experience to make your life really, truly better?

After a year, you’re free to use that other critical lens again, but my hope for you is your mind will have adjusted with the development of a second lens and that you’ll find a greater balance in your experience with storytelling.

My hope is you come to understand criticism is not the relentless dismantling of a piece of art but a balanced understanding of your personal, individual relationship with it, and I hope you come to understand you get to choose what you take from a piece of art, that it isn’t something a creator bestowed upon you for you to either wholly accept or reject. I hope you come to understand you get to choose what to draw from the art you consume.

And I hope you simply remember to enjoy storytelling again. I hope you remember why you came to love it in the first place. Life is too short for you to dislike the stories you experience, and the world is already too mean for you to exhale your pent-up bitterness into the atmosphere. Pick out the good stuff. Breathe fresh, clean air.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *